Instant Utility Approach to the Social Sciences

E-mail Print PDF

                                Thomas E. Chamberlain, Ph.D.*

       “Given that the only certain fact is the intensity of pleasure felt at an instant of
      time, the only epistemologically sound approach is to take intensity as the primary
      concept.” Georgescu-Roegen, in his introduction to the English translation of
      Hermann Gossen’s book on behavioral theory ([1854] 1983, lxxxi).

It is of course true of science that deeper theory opens new vistas, and economics may now
justifiably advance to a more essential paradigm. The basis for this deeper theory is empirical
(cardinal and measurable) instant utility (feeling state, Dolan [2002])—the time derivative of
utility (satisfaction). Immediate benefits could include: Reconciling sociology and economics
(both could now agree that wants, desires, satisfactions, etc. are endogenous); more correct
modeling of time and (periodic) human activity in microeconomics; modeling macroeconomic
equilibrium-states as a locus of dynamic states; and the substantive modeling of bounded
rationality, including uncertainty and expected risk. Because socioeconomic theory could now be
derived from deeper instant utility theory, the several branches may be unified in an overarching
classification. As a demonstration herein, Real Business Cycle Theory and Equilibrium Theory
are connected or related by a sequence of definitional assumptions on the basis of instant-utility
theory (the Gossen Equation). Then, after presenting the mathematical formulation of instant-
utility theory, Ramsey’s rule for saving is extended to account for expected-risk and autonomic
discounting. Finally, the prospect for greater cooperation between sociology and economics is
addressed. ...It may be emphasized that much of the important and far-reaching progress in
economics and social psychology over the past 100+ years is naturally accommodated by the
instant-utility theory. This progress includes the rationality assumption, diminishing marginal
rates of substitution, the theory of the firm in economics; and social-identity theory in social
psychology. Furthermore the historical bases for finite interest rates—time preference, better
times ahead, shortness of life, increasing technological knowledge, diminishing vitality in later
years, and risk—may be substantively formulated.

Instant_Utility Approach--9-16-11a.pdf

Note: This paper, originally completed in July 2003 and briefly refined for SSRN upload in 2004, is
unchanged herein except for clarifying refinements of (non-mathematical) text. However, it should be
noted that a recent paper—“Fully Temporal System Linking Productivity to Risk and Yielding
Completed Input/Output Substitution.” (2011; (Available on the Social Science Research Network:—has integrated neoclassical and Gossenian utility theory, and
unified or joined the corresponding (previously separate) economic systems.